Almost all of us eat, at times, out of the need for comfort. And those of us who raise children probably also feed to comfort them. Bad day? Are you upset? Sad? You’re troubled but don’t know exactly why? Food! Nipple, bottle, cookie, chocolate, pizza night, or maybe let’s go out and eat! And food, well, let’s be fair –really does act, for a few moments at least, as something that resembles comfort, like a gentle caress in loving hands.
Food ‘comforts’ us (i.e. provides a nice feeling in general) in a variety of ways, of which one is related to our comfort zone. Our comfort zone is a state of being we don’t want to move away from, because, well… it’s comforting there. It’s familiar, we feel safe and confident there, and the comfort derives from the ability to anticipate the results of our actions.
Emotional eating is a choice that resides deep within our comfort zone. We are used to emotional eating from infancy. Few things are more familiar, and so it is easily accessible, socially accepted and even advanced, and for most – the physical cost is not too overwhelming. Indeed, very comfortable. And when something is comfortable, well, it comforts…
When dealing with an emotional challenge, however small, the last thing that we feel like doing is to leave our comfort zone and to add difficulties. This seems like precisely the right time to withdraw to the familiar, the acceptable, the accepted, which will deliver a known outcome (if only briefly).
The above list of benefits for emotional eating (that it’s familiar, acceptable, accepted and delivers known outcomes) suggests that the true feeling of comfort is actually only a small component within the decision to turn to food when times are rough.
And yet, in our story of emotional eating, comfort is the most heavily noted, and thus – the most familiar.
One of my favourite tools when working with people involves deconstructing stories that we tell ourselves, and suggesting the construction of new ones in their stead. The work involves an abundance of love and great sensitivity, since there’s always a good reason as to why we had a need for the story that we held on to, for so long, and these are ships that should not be carelessly rocked on stormy tides.
Based on what you’ve read, I would suggest checking with yourself whether there’s an alternative story to your emotional eating. It does not always have to be a perfect fit. Even if it only allows us to consider its relevance, now and again, and to check if and how it serves us to ignite change – that will be enough.
When we consume comfort food, we tell ourselves that we needed comfort, but that is only rarely the case. On most occasions, ‘comfort’ is simply the shorthand, and the least painful way to refer to our real need, replacing things such as the need for appreciation, love, recognition, touch, meaning, and more.
Often, we don’t have the time, patience or tools to deal with our deep and unsatisfied needs. Our ‘comfort’ hides them for us, and we can’t be bothered to address them or the difficulty in satisfying them. We’re entitled to do that. But it’s important to note that sometimes we do it because we think that letting go of the comfort narrative leaves the need to deal with our deep needs as the only alternative. However, there’s actually a ‘third way’, another alternative, which also uses the term comfort, but is far less demanding on our emotional makeup. It’s the comfort zone.
What if, instead of telling ourselves a story about imprecise comforts, we tell ourselves about our comfort zone and its importance for us? What if we remember that, amidst all the difficulties and unsatisfied needs, we are driven towards the familiar and the comfortable, the accessible and the effective? Emotional eating is the turn towards comfort food, instead of turning to the comfort zone.
This story of comfort may not be complete, but at least it’s accurate. In contrast, the story of comfort is often not only incomplete, but acts to hide our truth from us.
You might like to read :
Most professionals in the field of nutrition will tell you that breakfast is the most important meal of your day. The logic for this claim is quite clear, but it is based on fear(s) and so should raise your suspicion. The main fear is that if you don’t eat early in the morning, you will […]
It seems advisable to talk about the ‘post-holiday’ diet before the holidays, for that is when a decision is made to embark on it. Or perhaps, more accurately, to embark on it again, for the same decision was made in previous holidays, and in those that preceded them, etc. The ‘post-holiday’ diet is the most […]
In the world of “eating habits” (a common euphemism for the world of diets) there are well known and common pearls of wisdom which are inefficient. Facially, they seem reasonable and helpful, stemming from common sense and accrued wisdom. But in fact, they are not only unhelpful, but plainly harmful. These include, for example “eat […]
Those who talk about the ‘right diet’ (‘diet’ here is used in the sense of ‘what we eat’, rather than ‘how to lose weight’) tend to assume that there are good and valid rules for the general population. Even where lip service is paid, by conceding that an individual’s needs must be accounted for, at […]
Why is it so important to decipher our emotional eating? First and foremost, to understand what we’re doing, we need to stop referring to emotional eating in euphemisms such as ‘comfort’ food or a ‘treat’, when their effect on us is actually neither. Poor food is not a treat, but rather burdens our body […]
“I’m eating this … for my soul”. Almost always only half-serious, half-joking nudge-nudge, wink-wink. But souls … souls don’t eat earthly food. Souls eat love. That is what feeds and nurtures them. And yet, the peculiar phrase is very common and relatable almost to all. It would be difficult to find someone who does not make […]
Emotional eating is one of the most common reasons for excessive consumption of inadequate food. For some, it leads to weight gain; others suffer from health problems; and there are those that confront frustration and the inability to lead a productive work or creative life. For many, emotional eating creates a vicious circle that consists […]
Does this sound familiar: dinner just ended, everyone finished their meal full and happy, and there’s no chance that anyone is hungry. And yet, a young one asks for food, in a small voice, which signals hunger: ‘Mum/dad… I’m hungry’. Hunger triggers us, mums and dads alike (let alone grandparents). It is seen as […]
Almost all of us eat, at times, out of the need for comfort. And those of us who raise children probably also feed to comfort them. Bad day? Are you upset? Sad? You’re troubled but don’t know exactly why? Food! Nipple, bottle, cookie, chocolate, pizza night, or maybe let’s go out and eat! And food, […]
It’s new year’s eve and you know the feeling. It’s a day like any other, really, but, in a manner that is completely unrelated to your physical reality, you make a very physical decision like … I’ll stop eating sugar. I’ll quit on meat. No more coffee. Or simply … I’ll lose weight, I’ll start […]
A gross estimate would suggest that about 90 per cent of the people I work with are drawn to emotional eating as a response to a victim mentality. Victimization presents a vast spectrum. At the one extreme, we find true victimization, in which an individual is treated in a manner that is cruel or unjust, […]
Many of our dietary challenges stem from our difficulties, or even inabilities, to identify real hunger in time and to address it in a fitting manner. Hunger is a very basic need, not different from the need to empty our bowels, to sleep or to have sex. Our engagement with hunger as a need can […]
Quite a few people who work with me ask for my help to rid themselves of drinking coffee in general, or to reduce quantities. My first response to such a request is that the first thing that a person should rid herself of is the expectation that habit that is kicked out the door will […]